This article is the second in a two-part series about the shortcomings of protected area definition in Peru. Read the first part here.
In a study published recently in PLOS ONE, researchers examined Peru’s network of protected areas. They found that many of these don’t exist in the areas most important for preserving the country’s biodiversity and addressing its threats, and suggest alternatives to make the system more effective.
To understand the conservation gaps identified through this study, it is first necessary to know what a conservation goal is. In site-selection terminology, as the paper points out, a species conservation goal is the amount of a species’ range that must be included within a reserve system for it to be considered sufficiently protected. For example, species designated Critically Endangered by the IUCN have small distributions and greater conservation needs than those designated Least Concern. A species is considered insufficiently protected by the existing protected areas system when the protected proportion of its range is below its conservation goal.
The study showed many of Peru’s species are inadequately safeguarded, with threatened species less protected than non-threatened species. All of Peru’s species listed as Critically Endangered by the IUCN, 86 percent of its Endangered species and 62 percent of its Vulnerable species failed to achieve their conservation goals.
The study found Peru’s rainforest areas tended to be better protected than its coastal and Andean regions. Photo taken in the Amazon rainforest near Iquitos, Peru, by Morgan Erickson-Davis.
For a more realistic and long-term solution to filling conservation gaps in the current system, the study prioritized proposed conservation areas using three criteria: selection frequency, vulnerability, and connectivity. Selection frequency represents the importance of a proposed area under various conditions, vulnerability highlights impacted areas with a higher urgency for protection, and connectivity aims to identify areas that maximize movement across protected areas. The authors highlight connectivity as particularly important for species that have large territories and that may not be holistically protected through a single protected area.
The study further identifies 94 areas of maximum suitability for conservation across Peru. Together, they represent almost 160,000 square kilometers or 12 percent of the country – which is roughly the same amount of area already under protection. While 66 of the proposed areas are independent from existing protected regions, 28 are extensions of current protected areas and nine of them could act as corridors between existing reserves. Among these are 26 high priority areas that lie mostly in the coastal and Andean regions of the country, especially towards the north. Most of the Amazonian areas were categorized as low priority because the human impact is far higher in the coastal area, for example, where five of Peru’s largest cities lie.
One of the main problems encountered during the course of this study, lead author Javier Fajardo told mongabay.com, was the lack of available open access and digitized information on biodiversity distribution.
“We had to construct the biodiversity distribution information based on statistical models that relate the presence of the species to environmental factors that are favorable for the presence of the species, and that is one of the big achievement (sic.) of the paper,” Fajardo said. “It is said that conservation is a science of urgency, so we need to start working on the available data even if it is not perfect.” Although this study accounted for over 2,800 species, Fajardo claims it is only a small percentage of all Peruvian species that have been described. “In my master thesis defense, a mycologist doctor on the tribunal was upset that I did not include fungus in the analyses. It had been impossible, because the scientific community lacks the knowledge for that,” he said.
Peru’s forests host high levels of biodiversity, and are home to many species of plants and animals like this phasmid insect. Photo by Morgan Erickson-Davis.
Like several other studies before it, this study too finds Peru’s national system of protected areas does an inadequate job of protecting biodiversity. Additionally, with evident conservation gaps in the three geographical zones, the need for creating new reserves to complement existing ones is emphasized. It also indicates that the protected area network is biased towards the Amazon ecosystem and humid forests, and calls for a more balanced, representative system.
Fajardo believes that nations would be better off improving the effectiveness of existing reserves before bringing in more area under protection. “In general, I think of PAs (protected areas) as a kind of auto-imposed condition that we human (sic.) create to hold ourselves a little back from using natural resources. So, in essence, I think they are good and I believe in them.”
However, the study is not without its caveats. The authors acknowledge its algorithms only consider connectivity at a basic level.
“That’s the reason why I incorporated it as a post-hoc analysis,” Fajardo told mongabay.com. Fajardo thinks connectivity is probably the most important factor in conservation planning and can take it to the next level. “I have spent a lot of time thinking about how to incorporate connectivity to the very core of site selection algorithms,” he said, but he hasn’t yet found a better solution possibly because it isn’t easy to achieve using his current programming skills. “Considering connectivity to prioritize (as we did) is something good, but it would be better to consider it in the selection – I mean, to make connectivity a key element influencing the selection.”
The study found Peru’s protected areas may not be effectively protecting the country’s biodiversity from land use changes. According to data from Global Forest Watch, Peru lost about 1.5 million hectares of tree cover from 2001 to 2012, representing nearly 2 percent of the country’s total forest cover (however, not all tree cover loss is from deforestation; some may be attributable to plantation harvesting). Click to enlarge.
Expressing his alarm over the lack of protection for threatened species, Fajardo stresses the importance of having a well-connected, efficient protected area system in place to safeguard the future of some of these species. “It is the case of iconic species, such as the condor, the jaguar or the puma. You cannot save the species in the country with a single protected area. They have very large requirements in terms of area,” he said.
Conservation planning, Fajardo says, has proven to be beneficial in developed countries like Australia where scientific findings have been given due importance in the decision-making process. “Planning conservation always results in positive outcomes: expenses can be reduced and benefits can be increased.”
Fajardo, J., Lessmann, J., Bonaccorso, E., Devenish, C., & Muñoz, J. (2014). Combined Use of Systematic Conservation Planning, Species Distribution Modelling, and Connectivity Analysis Reveals Severe Conservation Gaps in a Megadiverse Country (Peru). PloS one, 9(12), e114367..
Hansen, M. C., P. V. Potapov, R. Moore, M. Hancher, S. A. Turubanova, A. Tyukavina, D. Thau, S. V. Stehman, S. J. Goetz, T. R. Loveland, A. Kommareddy, A. Egorov, L. Chini, C. O. Justice, and J. R. G. Townshend. 2013. “UMD Tree Cover Loss and Gain Area.” University of Maryland and Google. Accessed through Global Forest Watch on Feb. 26, 2015. www.globalforestwatch.com.
UNEP-WCMC, UNEP, and IUCN. “World Database on Protected Areas.” Accessed on Feb. 26, 2015. www.protectedplanet.net..
Rainforest loss increased in the 2000s, concludes new analysis
(02/25/2015) Loss of tropical forests accelerated roughly 60 percent during the 2000s, argues a paper published in the journal Geophysical Research Letters. The findings contradict previous research suggesting that deforestation slowed since the 1990s. The study is based on a map of 1990 forest cover developed last year by Do-Hyung Kim and colleagues from the University of Maryland. The map, which includes 34 countries that contain 80 percent of the world’s tropical forests, enabled the researchers to establish a consistent baseline for tracking forest cover change across regions and countries over time.
Study finds Peru’s protected areas aren’t where they should be
(02/25/2015) Many of the world’s protected areas may not be located in the areas that need them the most, according to a recently published study in the journal PLoS ONE. The study examined the effectiveness of Peru’s existing protected area system in holistically preserving the biodiversity in this megadiverse country, finding it inadequately protecting many of the country’s species.
‘Sustainable’ cacao company allegedly defies government’s call to halt plantation development
(02/13/2015) A company aiming to be the world’s largest producer of sustainable cacao, the bean used to make chocolate, appears to have ignored orders from the Peruvian government to cease operations for failing to provide justification for having razed what scientists say was more than 2,000 hectares of old-growth Amazonian rainforest.
Scientists warn investors on cacao company’s forest destruction in Peru
(02/06/2015) A prominent group of scientists have sounded the alarm over forest clearing by a cacao company in the Peruvian Amazon.
The Amazon’s oil boom: concessions cover a Chile-sized bloc of rainforest
(02/04/2015) Hungry for oil revenue, governments and fossil fuel companies are moving even further into one of the world’s last great wildernesses, according to a new study in the journal Environmental Research Letters. The total area set aside for oil and gas in the Western Amazon has grown by 150,000 square kilometers since 2008, now totaling more than 730,000 square kilometers—an area the size of Chile.
Mercury fish: gold mining puts downstream communities at risk in Peru
(02/02/2015) Artisanal, often illegal gold-mining, has swept across portions of the Peruvian Amazon over last decade, driven in part by a rising price in gold. The unregulated industry has resulted in widespread deforestation leading to an environmental disaster. Now a new study finds that mercury pollution has moved rapidly downstream and could be impacting communities at least 560 kilometers away.
Video: camera trap catches jaguar hunting peccaries
(01/26/2015) Catching a jaguar on a remote camera trap in the Amazon is a rare, happy sight. But catching a jaguar attempting to ambush a herd of peccaries is quite simply astonishing.
Indigenous territories play dual role as homelands and protected areas
(01/22/2015) Indigenous communities claim—and scientific evidence increasingly shows—that indigenous forested territories are as well protected as, or better protected than, government-designated parks. In areas under pressure from roads or development projects, deforestation rates are sometimes even lower in indigenous territories than in official protected areas.
A model forest? Regional park balances local needs and conservation
(01/21/2015) Regional conservation area safeguards subsistence and spirituality in the Peruvian Amazon. For Alfredo Rojas, the history of the remote villages along the Ampiyacu River is one of enslavement. Growing up here, Rojas listened to his parents tell stories of the rubber barons who beat and killed the Indians who failed to meet their latex quota.