U.S. President Donald Trump’s administration recently repealed the 2024 Public Lands Rule, which established that conservation should have equal priority with industry when it comes to accessing leases for U.S. public land.
That shift in priorities will apply to 245 million acres (99 million hectares) of public land managed by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM). That’s roughly 10% of U.S. land that the agency leases for a multitude of private uses including grazing, mining, energy development and, until recently, conservation.
In the federal register the Department of the Interior (DOI) said, “[b]y rescinding the 2024 Rule, the BLM eliminates mechanisms — such as restoration and mitigation leasing — that threatened to restrict productive use of the public lands.”
An example of the decision’s impact can be found in the state of Montana. Roughly 950 American bison (Bison bison) have grazed on 63,000 acres (25,495 hectares) of federal land there since 2022. However, the DOI, which oversees BLM, revoked that grazing permit on May 8, just days before repealing the Public Lands Rule.
Interior secretary Doug Burgman said that according to federal grazing laws, public land leases can only be given to animals, “intended for use primarily for their meat, milk, or other animal products.” He added that “considerable evidence” suggests the bison are intended for “for some other purpose, such as conservation.”
Before western settlement, upwards of 100 million bison roamed the plains, serving as “ecosystem engineers shape[ing] healthy and diverse ecological communities,” the DOI acknowledged in its 2020 Bison Conservation Initiative. Today, just 530,000 remain, mostly as livestock.
Historically, bison were crucial to the survival of Native Americans across the western U.S. “Bison are our relatives. We have ancestral and spiritual obligations to care for them, as they do us,” J. Garret Renville, chairman of the Native American Coalition of Large Tribes, wrote in a formal protest of the DOI decision. “Our success as a people is dependent on their success. Our history, our futures, and our fates are intertwined.”
Alison Fox, CEO of American Prairie, the Montana-based NGO that owns the bison herd in question, said in a statement that “this decision abandons decades of consistent federal policy.”
The Western Watersheds Project, an Idaho-based NGO, said BLM is “inventing a wholly new standard for livestock grazing permits in order to justify their pro-cattle bias.”
Renville said as the decision is written, “it is unlikely that any tribal government or tribal citizen buffalo herd would ever be eligible for BLM grazing leases.”
The BLM has said American Prairie bison must be removed by Sept. 30. In an email to Mongabay, American Prairie said, “we are still waiting for a decision on our request for a preliminary injunction.”
BLM declined to comment since the case is pending litigation.
Banner image: Bison and calves in Lamar Valley of Yellowstone National Park. Image courtesy of U.S. National Park Service.