The body of a bird killed in a window strike. Birds mistake the reflective glass as a clear flight path, flying into the window at full speed. Photo by: Paige Shoemaker.
The sickening thud of a bird crashing into a window is an all-too-familiar sound for many Canadian homeowners. Birds often mistake windows for openings, flying into the glass at full speed. A startling new analysis suggests about 22 million Canadian birds die each year from such crashes, researchers reported Sept. 4 in Wildlife Research.
Undergraduate biology students at the University of Alberta, supervised by biologist Erin Bayne, surveyed 1,750 local residents in person and through social media. The recruited citizens provided the number of fatal bird strikes at their homes during the previous year. By extrapolating from these local reports, the researchers calculated the collision rates for different types of homes and then estimated the national bird mortality rate. The study did not include bird strikes on skyscrapers or commercial buildings.
“Most houses have had zero collisions in the last year, but others had many more,” Bayne told mongabay.com. Rural houses with bird feeders and lots of vegetation generally had more bird fatalities—as many as 43 in a year.
Bird silhouette adhered to a window. Using stickers or objects to break up a window’s reflection can help prevent bird deaths. Photo by: Sharat Ganapati.
“Not surprisingly, when you have more birds present you have more collisions,” Bayne said.
Common birds, like sparrows, robins and chickadees, accounted for most casualties. Bayne’s study found no endangered birds killed by windows, but he mentioned that for an endangered species, “even a few collisions could have a big impact.”
“This is not just an Albertan issue or a Canadian issue,” Bayne said. “This is an important issue in countries around the world.” In the United States, for example, an estimated 100 million to 1 billion birds die each year by crashing into windows.
Previous bird-window mortality estimates looked at fewer homes and didn’t include factors that can make some houses deadlier than others. Biologist Scott Loss of the Smithsonian Migratory Bird Center in Washington, D.C., said Bayne’s methods are a big improvement.
“Using the fact that different buildings have different collision rates is much better than trying to generalize one collision rate for all buildings,” said Loss in an interview with mongabay.com. “In terms of scale, this study sets a good new precedent for other studies to try to achieve.”
Bayne admits his method isn’t perfect; homeowners won’t remember every bird collision over the course of a year. His group is developing an online database where residents can report incidents as they happen. However, Bayne said, the exact tally isn’t what’s most important.
“It’s a very large number regardless of how you estimate it,” he said. “The question is, do we need to get better numbers to convince people that this is an issue, or do we need to start doing something about it?”
For homeowners looking to prevent traumatic bird deaths, the easiest step is to move bird gathering spots, like feeders and birdbaths, farther away from windows. The dark silhouette of a hawk, owl or falcon works well as a window covering—not because it mimics a predator, but because it breaks up the smooth reflection of the glass. Placing stickers or plastic wrap on the outside of the window also can prevent a bird from perceiving a clear flight path.
“People need to really think about what’s best for the birds and not just what’s best for them viewing the birds,” Bayne said.
The imprint of a pigeon on a window. Common birds made up the bulk of window fatalities in a recent Canadian study. Photo by: Gary Huston.
CITATION: Bayne, EM, Scobie, CA, and Rawson-Clark, M. (2012) Factors influencing the annual risk of bird–window collisions at residential structures in Alberta, Canada. Wildlife Research 39(7) 583-592 http://www.publish.csiro.au/nid/144/paper/WR11179.htm
Thomas Sumner is a graduate student in the Science Communication Program at the University of California, Santa Cruz.
(11/15/2012) Crows may be imagining more than we imagined. New research suggests certain crows make decisions based on factors they can’t see. A recent study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) deepens our understanding of these crafty corvids, and could help explain how human reasoning evolved. Crows are intelligent problem solvers, capable of making hook-shaped tools to retrieve food and using multiple tools in a logical sequence. New Caledonian crows (Corvus moneduloides) are particularly adept tool users, and have often been the subject of cognitive research. In this study, the New Zealand–based researchers tested whether New Caledonian crows could trace an event back to a cause that was hidden from their view.
(11/08/2012) In a choice between flamingoes and a soda ash plant, a new report shows that local residents near Lake Natron, Tanzania prefer flamingoes. This is good news for conservationists as the area is the most important breeding site in the world for lesser flamingos (Phoenicopterus minor). While the report shows agreement between residents and conservation groups that the project isn’t worth its cost or risk, the Tanzanian government is not giving up yet.
(11/02/2012) Scientists have created an evolutionary maps for all the world’s nearly 10,000 bird species. The ‘tree of life’ is published in the current issue of the journal Nature.
(11/01/2012) A life on the ocean is a perilous one for any bird. They must expend energy staying aloft for thousands of miles and learn to be marathon swimmers; they must seek food beneath treacherous waves and brave the world’s most extreme climates; they must navigate the perils both of an unforgiving sea and far-flung islands. Yet seabirds, which includes 346 global species that depend on marine ecosystems, have evolved numerous strategies and complex life histories to deal with the challenges of the sea successfully, and they have been doing so since the dinosaur’s last stand. Today, despite such a track record, no other bird family is more threatened; yet it’s not the wild, unpredictable sea that endangers them, but pervasive human impacts.
(10/31/2012) In a remote corner of the Ethiopian highlands in January 2011, the bright tropical light combined with the fresh and thin air at 3,600 metres. The Ethiopian bird-watching guide and conservationist, Yilma Dellelegn, from the Ethiopian Wildlife Society, was startled when he spotted two un-ringed young bald ibises, together with two ringed and well known adult females (Zenobia and Salam) at their wintering site. Considering the dwindling numbers, two unaccounted for young birds, literally popping out of the blue, were a great surprise—and precious! The sighting had the potential to raise intriguing geographic and behavioral questions: in fact, the riddle of the migration and wintering strategy of the oriental northern bald ibis (Geronticus eremita) was still half way from being solved.