Scientists propose a new way forward on orangutan conservation

Cynthia Malone, special to mongabay.com
July 16, 2012



Orangutan in Sumatra. Photo by: Rhett A. Butler.
Orangutan in Sumatra. Photo by: Rhett A. Butler.

Orangutans are in dire need of a revised conservation approach, according to a new study in the Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. While the plight of the species is widely recognized within the conservation community—receiving international attention in the form of scientific research, funding, and NGO efforts—the authors argue that "there has been frustratingly little progress."

Scientists predict the loss of most wild orangutan populations by 2025. This is not surprising when one considers that pervasive threats have led to a population decline of over 5,250 orangutans every year. Although efforts have been made to protect forests, the authors suggest that other threats have been ignored.

For wealthier countries, orangutans have become a symbol for deforestation in Indonesia and Malaysia, with palm oil as the "major culprit in the orangutans’ decline," according to the paper. Oil palm plantations destroy forests on which orangutans depend; the study estimated that 5% of the orangutan’s range has been converted for oil palm in the last ten years alone. The recent controversy of the destruction of orangutan habitat in the Tripa peat swamp forest of Sumatra demonstrates that even government efforts to prevent forest conversion to oil palm are often ignored. However, the study argues that even though palm oil continues to pose a serious threat to orangutan survival, it is dangerous to focus efforts on a single disruptive practice. Hunting, long ignored within the conservation community, also severely threatens orangutans. Recent research has shown that current reported hunting rates greatly exceed orangutan reproductive rates, which are extremely low compared to most mammals. For example, between 700 to 3,500 orangutans are killed annually in Kalimantan, Indonesian Borneo according to scientists.

Orangutan in Tanjung Puting National Park in Kalimantan, Indonesia. Photo by: Cynthia Malone.
Orangutan in Tanjung Puting National Park in Kalimantan, Indonesia. Photo by: Cynthia Malone.
Given that conservation resources are limited, understanding how orangutans respond to threats is crucial to the survival of the species alongside an expanding human population.

"[Saving orangutans] will require that we stop seeing conservation in black and white terms of unprotected and protected or natural and unnatural," the authors write.

Currently, orangutan conservationists often channel resources to establish new protected areas based on the premise that orangutans cannot cope with habitat disturbance. The review provides evidence to the contrary, however, highlighting research on orangutan populations surviving in previously logged forests and monoculture plantations. According to the authors, this demonstrates the "considerable ecological flexibility" of the species.

Since 75% of orangutans exist in unprotected areas, which could be logged or converted at anytime, this tolerance for disturbance is cause for hope in a time when securing additional protected habitat is unlikely. Instead of vying for protected habitat, the scientists recommend that research and resources be directed towards supporting multi-functional landscapes that provide "viable habitat for orangutans as well as people." With greater knowledge of how orangutans respond to disturbance, comprehensive management could be instituted in unprotected areas, simultaneously accommodating the interests of local communities, agriculture, and development projects.

"I want to look at people, land-use, economic value, the role of business in conservation, any of the things that can make a change," lead author Erik Meijaard told mongabay.com. After all, the underlying causes of habitat loss and hunting are human-derived: inefficient land use planning and forest management by Indonesian and Malaysian governments allows the destruction and degradation of orangutan areas. Inadequate law enforcement also allows orangutan-killing to largely go unpunished.

With over 20 years of conservation experience in Indonesia, Meijaard says that the conservation community needs to develop an inter-disciplinary approach that would define new goals, such as maintaining sustainable multi-functional landscapes. This would be a break from the traditional focus on ecological and behavioral research of orangutans that treats conservation as a "serendipitous afterthought" rather than a primary objective according to the paper. While the efforts of orangutan scientists and NGOs could improve, the authors emphasize that the responsibility for the persistence of orangutans in the wild ultimately lies with the Indonesian and Malaysian governments.

"Abating the threat to orangutan survival is a political choice requiring societal approval and cooperation for comprehensive solutions that involve strict protection of key habitats, effective law enforcement against harmful illegal activities, and selection of compatible land-use practices," the authors write.

In addition, the paper argues that there is a dire need for more involvement from Indonesian and Malaysian scientists, as an earlier study reported they authored only 1% of publications including the keywords "orangutan/orang-utan" and "conservation." Indigenous researchers could potentially play a great role in enabling societal change on the ground and harnessing political recognition of conservation.

"Losing a great ape from the wild would be a landmark failure," the authors assert. Beyond the importance of orangutans as our close genetic relatives, the species have important ecological roles as seed dispersers and ecosystem engineers. Destruction of orangutan habitat also results in the destruction of habitat for countless species that share the same forests, including many that are also native only to Indonesia and Malaysia. Furthermore, people who reside in or near forests depend on its natural resources for their livelihoods.

As with efforts to protect any species, the authors assert that orangutan conservation requires not just research, but creative, cross-disciplinary thinking that considers ecosystems and all stakeholders. The dedication of conservationists has led to some successes—such as acquiring legal protection for key orangutan habitat—but if the species is to persist in the wild a paradigm shift is needed.



CITATION: Meijaard, E., Wich, S., Ancrenaz, M. and Marshall, A. J. (2012), Not by science alone: why orangutan conservationists must think outside the box. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1249: 29–44.


Cynthia Malone is a Zoology and Anthropology undergraduate researching the oil palm industry in Indonesia as a summer research fellow at the Center for Sustainability and the Global Environment (SAGE) at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.















Related articles

Pictures: mama and baby orangutan saved from palm oil developers

(05/19/2012) A mother orangutan and its baby were rescued from an area of forest that was being bulldozed for an oil palm plantation in Sumatra, reports the Orangutan Information Centre (OIC), which participated in the translocation of the red apes.


Green groups may call for boycott of Indonesian palm oil over forest destruction in Sumatra

(04/11/2012) Environmental groups are escalating their battle over an area of peat forest in Tripa, Sumatra that has been granted for oil palm plantations.


Governor of Aceh who signed palm oil permit: plantation in Tripa "morally wrong"

(04/05/2012) The former governor of Aceh, Irwandi Yusuf, told The Sydney Morning Herald today that an oil palm plantation he approved was "not wrong legally, but wrong morally." Irwandi, who is currently seeking re-election, signed off on the hugely controversial plantation in deep peat forest last August, but the issue came to a head this week as satellite images showed a dozen fires burning in the concession area known as Tripa. Environmental groups, which are running an online campaign, warn that the burning is imperiling an important population of Critically Endangered Sumatran orangutans (Pongo abelii).


Environmentalists, orangutans lose court case over palm oil

(04/03/2012) Environmentalists were handed a set back in a dispute over a palm oil plantation granted in a protected peat swamp that is home to a population of critically endangered orangutans, reports the Aceh Globe and the Sydney Morning Herald.


Busted: orangutan trafficker prosecuted and sent to prison in Sumatra for the first time

(02/23/2012) For the first time in Medan, North Sumatra, an orangutan trader has been prosecuted and sent to prison for trafficking in the endangered apes, reports the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS).


Orangutans in Indonesian Borneo doomed to extinction?

(11/14/2011) A new study finds orangutans in Indonesian Borneo in unprotected areas are being killed at a rate faster than what population viability analysis considers sustainable. Conflict between orangutans and humans is worst in areas that have been fragmented and converted for timber, wood-pulp, and palm oil production, but hunting is occurring in relatively intact forest zones away from industrial development.







CITATION:
Cynthia Malone, special to mongabay.com (July 16, 2012).

Scientists propose a new way forward on orangutan conservation .

http://news.mongabay.com/2012/0716-malone-orangutans.html