In the new book, On Gaia: A Critical Investigation of the Relationship between Life and Earth, Dr. Toby Tyrrell analyzes 40-years of data for and against the Gaia hypothesis. Dr. James Lovelock, along Dr. Lynn Margulis, co-developed the Gaia Hypothesis in the 1970s. The Gaia Hypothesis suggests that life itself, in unison across species and through complex interactions, controls the inorganic structures and forms of the Earth.
Many scientists have reacted to the Gaia Hypothesis, either strongly for the notion of a self-regulating web of life that manages the Earth as whole, or against this concept. In On Gaia: A Critical Investigation of the Relationship between Life and Earth, Dr. Toby Tyrrell, for the first time, conducts a lengthy analysis of the scientific data for and against the Gaia Hypothesis. He concludes that the Gaia Hypothesis does not have enough scientific data to support it. He write eloquently, clearly, and succinctly describing how the Gaia Hypothesis lacks sufficient scientific evidence.
Dr. Tyrrell’s analysis of the Gaia Hypothesis is important for those interested in tropical forest conservation. This is because if we determine that the scientific data supports the Gaia Hypothesis and the Earth, as a collection of organic organisms, as a whole is self-regulating to maintain hospitable equilibrium of the inorganic aspects of the Earth, then we would have no need ecologically to conserve tropical forests. Yet, as Dr. Tyrrell discusses at length, it is our lack of conservative environmental stewardship that may make the Earth an inhospitable environment for us and most other species, which disproves the Gaia Hypothesis.
Even today, we hear in the popular press, “climate change is bad for humans, but the Earth’s ecology will be fine if climate change occurs.” This is a statement derived from the Gaia Hypothesis, and it promotes inaction on climate change. As scientists, we need to promote action to mitigate climate change and its associated biodiversity collapse, not support conservation inaction.
Dr. Tyrrell provides a fair and reflective analysis of the Gaia Hypothesis. He describes pros and cons in a well-written easy to read book that is great read for those with an elementary scientific background.
How to order:
Paperback: On Gaia: A Critical Investigation of the Relationship between Life and Earth
Publisher: Princeton University Press
Editors: Toby Tyrrell
ISBN: 9781400847914
Gabriel Thoumi, CFA is a globally recognized international climate finance expert and natural resources scientist.
Related articles
Novel Ecosystems: Intervening in the New Ecological World Order – book review
(08/12/2013) Novel Ecosystems: Intervening in the New Ecological World Order is a recent textbook published by Wiley-Blackwell edited by Richard J. Hobbs, Eric S. Higgs, and Carol M. Hall that describes the emerging issues around novel ecosystems. Novel ecosystems are rapidly developing globally in response to land conversion, climate change, invasive species, and other ecological crises. Novel ecosystems are anthropogenically modified ecosystems that have developed during the Anthropocene.
Climate Myths: how climate denialists are getting away with bad science
(04/29/2013) In Climate Myths: The Campaign Against Climate Science, Dr. John J. Berger deconstructs the climate change denialists’ myths in simple, easy-to-read terms. According to the Pew Research Center: “Nearly seven-in-ten (69%) [Americans] say there is solid evidence that the earth’s average temperature has been getting warmer over the past few decades, up six points since November 2011 and 12 points since 2009.” Yet implementing national-level climate change mitigation legislation is not occurring in the U.S.
Carbon Management in the Built Environment – book review
(04/02/2013) Carbon Management in the Built Environment, written by Rohinton Emmanuel and Keith Baker, is the complete introductory textbook covering low carbon management for the built environment. Carbon Management in the Built Environment integrates climate change science, design, materials science, and policy into a classroom friendly text.
Carbon Markets or Climate Finance – book review
(03/25/2013) Carbon markets or climate finance? This is the question posed by Carbon Markets or Climate Finance, edited by Axel Michaelowa. First of all, let’s define climate finance as the financial resources used to mitigate and adapt to climate change.