Capturing and storing the carbon dioxide could be key in minimizing climate change

Capturing and storing the carbon dioxide could be key in minimizing climate change
UN press release
September 26, 2005

MONTREAL, 26 September (UNEP/WMO) — A new assessment report finalized here today by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) concludes that capturing and storing the carbon dioxide (CO2) produced by power plants and factories before it enters the atmosphere could play a major role in minimizing climate change.

“While the most important solutions to climate change will remain energy efficiency and cleaner energy sources, this new report demonstrates that capturing and storing carbon dioxide can supplement these other efforts”, said Executive Director Klaus Toepfer of the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP).

“Since emissions of carbon dioxide — the most important cause of climate change — continue to rise in many parts of the world, it is vital that we exploit every available option for reducing their impact on the global climate. CO2 capture and storage can clearly play a supporting role”, said Secretary-General Michel Jarraud of the World Meteorological Organization (WMO).

According to a number of studies, carbon dioxide capture and storage technologies (known as CCS) could lower the costs of mitigating climate change over the next 100 years by 30 per cent or more. In addition, capture and storage of CO2 in geological formations could account for 15 to 55 per cent of all emission reductions (equal to 220 to 2,200 billion tonnes (Gt) of CO2) needed between now and 2100 for stabilizing greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere.

Related articles Hurricane Katrina damage just a dose of what’s to come 21-September-2005 The kind of devastation seen on the Gulf Coast from Hurricane Katrina may be a small taste of what is to come if emissions of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide (CO2 ) are not diminished soon, warns Dr. Ken Caldeira of the Carnegie Institution’s Department of Global Ecology in his opening remarks at the 7th International Carbon Dioxide Conference in Boulder, Colorado, September 26, 2005. 90% of largest companies concerned about climate change — survey 18-September-2005 More U.S. corporations than ever before now factor climate change into the risks and opportunities faced by their businesses, according to a report released today by the Carbon Disclosure Project, a coalition of institutional investors with more than $21 trillion in assets. Increased interest from the investment community, in conjunction with related macro-economic developments, is encouraging the development of strategies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Humans impacted climate thousands of years ago September 9, 2005 New research suggests humans were influencing the world’s climate long before the Industrial Revolution. Atmospheric levels of methane, a potent greenhouse gas, climbed steadily during the first millennium due to massive fires set by humans clearing land for agriculture. The research, published in this week’s Science, is detailed below in three presss releases from sponsoring institutions. Carbon reinjection strategies to be affected by climate change September 8, 2005 An Earth System model developed by researchers at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign indicates that the best location to store carbon dioxide in the deep ocean will change with climate change. The direct injection of carbon dioxide deep into the ocean has been suggested as one method to help control rising carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere and mitigate the effects of global warming. But, because the atmosphere interacts with the oceans, the net uptake of carbon dioxide and the oceans’ sequestration capacity could be affected by climate change. Ocean gas hydrates could trigger catastrophic climate change September 6, 2005 Global warming will cause gasses trapped beneath the ocean floor to release into the atmosphere according to research presented at the Annual Conference of the Royal Geographical Society. The impact could initiate a catastrophic global greenhouse effect. Global warming may have triggered worst mass extinction August 29, 2005 A dramatic rise in carbon dioxide 250 million years ago may have caused global temperatures to soar and result in Earth’s greatest mass extinction, according to a study published in the September issue of Geology. Global warming, which may have produced temperatures 10 to 30 degrees Celsius higher than today, would have had a significant impact both on oceans, where about 95% of lifeforms became extinct, and on land, where almost 75% of species died out.

Many components of carbon dioxide capture and storage technology are already mature, including several applications of CO2 capture, pipelines and gas injection into geological formations. Three CCS projects are already in operation, in Algeria, Canada and the North Sea off the Norwegian coast. CO2 capture from large-scale power plants will require further demonstration over the coming years and decades. Other possible applications, such as ocean storage or fixing CO2 in stable carbonates, are still in a research phase.

The potential of capture and storage could be limited by several important non-technology constraints. In particular, unless Governments adopt climate change policies that put a cost on emitting CO2, there will be no incentive to use these technologies.

Furthermore, while the available storage capacity in geological reservoirs is “likely” to be sufficient, the true amount is yet uncertain. This is particularly so in some regions that are experiencing rapid economic growth, such as South and East Asia.

Because the CCS process requires energy, its adoption may increase the use of fossil fuels. For the same level of electricity production, a power plant with CO2 capture would require 10 to 40 per cent more energy than a plant without capture.

Under current conditions, producing electricity costs about $0.04–0.06/kWh (kilo-watt hour). Adopting today’s CCS technologies would raise this cost by an estimated $0.01–0.05/kWh. The future costs of CCS could decline due to technological advances and economies of scale — perhaps by 20 to 30 per cent over the next decade, assuming sustained research and development, and deployment. On the other hand, rising oil prices could influence CCS costs. The report finds that such estimates for the current and future costs of CCS have significant uncertainties.

For CCS systems to contribute to lowering emissions from power generation — the sector with by far the greatest potential for this technology — the price of carbon dioxide reductions would have to exceed $25-30/tCO2 (ton of CO2) over the lifetime of the project (in 2002 dollars). CCS could play a role in emissions trading or the Kyoto Protocol mechanisms, but a methodology to account for emissions reductions may need further elaboration.

The most economically feasible storage options for CO2 are geological formations, particularly given the experience already gained by the oil and gas industry. Fortunately, a large proportion of existing power plants and other “point sources” lie within 300 km of areas that potentially contain storage reservoirs, such as oil and gas fields, unminable coal beds and deep saline water-bearing formations.

Technologies for injecting captured CO2 into the oceans may also have potential, but they are still in the research phase and have not undergone full-scale testing. They involve releasing CO2 into the ocean water column via a fixed pipeline or a moving ship, or depositing it onto the deep sea-floor at depths below 3,000 m where CO2 is denser than water. There are concerns regarding the impact such technologies could have on ocean life and it is known that marine organisms could be harmed. Although the long-term environmental implications of changing the ocean chemistry in this way are unclear, the oceans could become significantly acidified if CO2 injection occurred on a large scale.

Technologies for storing CO2 virtually permanently by converting it into inorganic mineral carbonates are also in the research phase, and certain applications have been demonstrated on a small scale. The energy requirements for this technology, however, are still unfavourable and would need to be further improved before it could become a real option. Using captured CO2 for chemical processes in industry is technically possible but has hardly any potential for net reduction of CO2 emissions.

As important as technology and cost issues are, health, safety, environmental and legal concerns would also need to be addressed to ensure public support. Potential risks include leakage from capture, transport and injection (comparable to the risk in similar existing industrial operations) and slow leaks from storage sites (a low risk if reservoirs are carefully selected and best available technologies are used). A key legal issue would be how international law would treat CO2 injection activities in international seas.

The “IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage” was written by 100 experts from over 30 countries and reviewed by many experts and Governments. The report assesses the most up-to-date literature available in scientific and technical journals around the world and was requested by the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). The IPCC was launched by WMO and UNEP in 1988.

This is a modified United Nations’ press release