India, not China, has the world's worst urban air pollution

Jeremy Hance
mongabay.com
May 12, 2014



Breathing in urban India is hard: of the world's top twenty cities with the worst air, 13 of them are found in India, according to a new analysis by the World Health Organization (WHO). Despite the attention recently given to Chinese cities for atrocious air pollution, many of India's cities are actually worse when comparing annual averages of fine airborne particulates.

The WHO looked at PM2.5 or airborne particulates less than 10 micrometers in diameter over a calendar year; PM2.5s are considered especially dangerous because they are easily respirated into the lungs leading to health problems such as lung cancer, heart disease, asthma, and bronchitis.

Surveying 1,600 cities in 91 countries, the WHO found that New Delhi's air was the worst in the world with average of 153 PM2.5 micrograms per cubic meter. Three other Indian cities—Patna, Gwalior, and Raipur—round out the top four, with Karachi, Pakistan as the fifth worse in the world.

None of China's cities came in the top 20. In fact, the Chinese city suffering from the worst air pollution was Lanzhou at number 36. Beijing, which gets a lot of media attention, is actually number 77.

Air monitoring in New Delhi. Photo by: Fredericknoronha.
Air monitoring in New Delhi. Photo by: Fredericknoronha/Creative Commons 3.0.

The WHO says that air pollution should not be more than 10 PM2.5 micrograms per cubic meter to be deemed safe. But more than 1,100 of the cities on the list had levels of 11 or above. New Delhi air was more than 1,500 percent above the recommended level, and Beijing's nearly 800 percent. However the WHO cautioned that some of the world's most polluted cities may not be on the list.

"Many cities in the world, including some expected to be among the most polluted, do not collect information or report on its outdoor air quality. WHO therefore cannot compare cities based on their levels of outdoor air pollution," says the WHO.

Still the new analysis allows easy side-by-side comparisons and paints a broad picture of air pollution worldwide. Worryingly, the analysis found that 90 percent of the global urban population (based on these 1,600 cities) were exposed to unsafe air pollution.

Government scientists from India have bashed the analysis saying that New Delhi's levels were too high and Beijing's too low. But one of the scientists contested that New Delhi averaged about 110 micrograms over the year, which is still 1,100 percent above the recommended level and a level that would land it in the top 10.

Air pollution is caused by burning fossil fuels for energy, motor vehicles, industry, and in some parts of the world cook stoves that use biomass or coal. India is heavily dependent on coal-fired energy: currently the country uses coal for over 60 percent of its energy and is planning on building over 400 new coal plants.

A report last year by Conservation Action Trust and Greenpeace-India found that burning coal in India likely led to 80,000-115,000 deaths annually, including 10,000 children under five. In addition to being heavily-polluting, coal is also the most carbon-intensive fuel source causing climate change.

Girls in India. Photo by: Nancy Butler.
Girls in India. Photo by: Nancy Butler.

Top Twenty Cities for Air Pollution based on 2.5 PM from the WHO
  • 1. Delhi, India: 153
  • 2. Patna, India: 149
  • 3. Gwalior, India: 144
  • 4. Raipur, India: 134
  • 5. Karachi, Pakistan: 117
  • 6. Peshwar, Pakistan: 111
  • 7. Rawalpindi, Pakistan: 107
  • 8. Khoramabad, Iran: 102
  • 9. Ahmedabad, India: 100
  • 10. Lucknow, India: 96
  • 11. Firozabad, India: 96
  • 12. Doha, Qatar: 93
  • 13. Kanpur, India: 93
  • 14. Amritsar, India: 92
  • 15. Ludhiana, India: 91
  • 16. Igdir, Turkey: 90
  • 17. Narayonganj, Bangladesh: 89
  • 18. Allahabad, India: 88
  • 19. Khanna, India: 88
  • 20. Agra, India: 88














AUTHOR: Jeremy Hance joined Mongabay full-time in 2009. He currently serves as senior writer and editor. He has also authored a book.




Related articles

Logging giant suspends operations to fend off plantations from fires

(03/15/2014) Indonesian Pulp & paper giant Asia Pacific Resources International Limited (APRIL) says it has suspended operations at a concession in Riau Province in order to shift staff toward fighting back fires that threaten its plantations. In a statement issued Friday, APRIL said its plantations on Pulau Padang, a peat island off the coast of Sumatra, are at risk due to fires illegally set outside its concessions.


Sumatra on fire: burning spikes in Indonesia

(03/13/2014) Fires in Sumatra's Riau province have spiked to levels unseen since last June, finds new analysis from the World Resources Institute (WRI) that reveals widespread burning within concessions managed by pulpwood, palm oil, and logging companies.


NASA photo reveals ongoing haze problem in Sumatra

(03/01/2014) A new satellite image released by NASA highlights Indonesia's ongoing problem with haze caused by land-clearing fires set across carbon-dense peatlands on the island of Sumatra.


Emissions outsourced to China return to U.S. in form of air pollution

(01/20/2014) Twenty percent of China's air pollution can be attributed to goods exported to America, with some of those emissions drifting back to the Western United States, finds a study published this week in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.


Bangladesh plans massive coal plant in world's biggest mangrove forest

(11/11/2013) On October 22nd Bangladeshi and Indian officials were supposed to hold a ceremony laying the foundation stone for the Rampal power plant, a massive new coal-fired plant that will sit on the edge of the Sundarbans, the world's largest mangrove forest. However, the governments suddenly cancelled the ceremony, instead announcing that the project had already been inaugurated in early October by the countries' heads of state via a less-ornate Skype call. While the governments say the change was made because of busy schedules, activists contend the sudden scuttling of the ceremony was more likely due to rising pressure against the coal plant, including a five-day march in September that attracted thousands.


Shanghai to ban coal by 2017

(10/28/2013) China's largest city and one of the world's biggest, Shanghai, is set to ban coal burning in just four years, according to a new Clean Air Action Plan. The city-wide ban on coal burning is one effort among many to get Shanghai's infamous smog under control as well as another sign that China has begun to take its pollution problems more seriously.


WHO: air pollution causes cancer

(10/17/2013) Outdoor air pollution has been officially classified as carcinogenic by the cancer arm of the World Health Organization. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) said air pollution from traffic and industrial fumes was a definite cause of lung cancer and also linked to bladder cancer. The strong verdict from IARC, a cautious body that pronounces only when the evidence is strong, will put pressure on governments to take action.


June fires concentrated in peatlands, burned 1,500 sq km in Sumatra

(10/16/2013) Fires that sent a choking haze across Singapore and Malaysia in June burned some 1,500 square kilometers in Riau Province and were predominantly concentrated on peatlands, reports the World Resources Institute (WRI).


China punishes top oil companies for failing to clean up their acts

(09/03/2013) China's top two oil companies have been penalized for missing pollution targets, reports China Central Television (CCTV). The Ministry of Environmental Protection has suspended all refinery projects for China National Petroleum Corporation (CPNC) and the China Petrochemical Corporation (Sinopec) until they meet their pollution targets. The move is a part of a wider crackdown on pollution across China, which has suffered from record air pollution.


500 fires rage across Sumatra

(08/29/2013) Nearly 500 fires are burning across the Indonesian island of Sumatra, raising fears that choking air pollution could return to Singapore and Malaysia.


China pledges $275 billion over 5 years to cut record air pollution

(08/19/2013) Last week China announced it was going to spend over a quarter of a trillion dollars ($275 billion) to fight rampant and life-threatening pollution in its urban centers over the next five years. Recent decades of unparalleled economic growth has taken a drastic environmental toll in China, including record air pollution levels in Beijing. The announcement follows other news, including that the Chinese government has recently scrapped a massive 2,000 megawatt coal plant project near the cities of Hong Kong and Shenzhen.







CITATION:
Jeremy Hance
mongabay.com (May 12, 2014).

India, not China, has the world's worst urban air pollution.

http://news.mongabay.com/2014/0512-hance-air-pollution-cities.html