July 06, 2010
According to Jean-Philippe Puyravaud and Priya Davidar of Pondicherry University, and William Laurance from James Cook University, the findings were very likely too optimistic.
"Unfortunately, as scientists who have long studied Asian forests, we believe that this view is misleading," the researchers write in a letter in Science.
They cite local studies that have shown that forests have decreased in some of India's most important conservation and biodiverse areas: the Western and Eastern Ghats, and the Himalayas.
In addition, the researchers point out that FSI employed automated analyses of forest satellite imagery to come up with its conclusion that forests were on the rise. However with such analyses comes a big problem.
With such a system "native forests are pooled with exotic tree plantations, such as eucalyptus, acacia, rubber, teak, or pine trees, which have very limited value for endangered biodiversity," the researchers explain. Many of these plantations and subsequent deforestation are driven by a huge demand for firewood.
Monoculture plantations are on the rise in India, expanding by nearly 6,000 square kilometers (2,300 square miles) to 18,000 square kilometers (nearly 7,000 square miles) per year.
"If one subtracts plantations from total forest cover then India’s native forests have actually declined at an alarming pace, from 0.8% to 3.5% per year," the researchers conclude. If these figures represent the reality on the ground, India is suffering from a higher rate of forest loss than either Brazil or Malaysia from 2000-2005.
"To me this illustrates the risks of our present over-reliance on satellite data to track changes in forest cover. It's pretty easy to estimate total forest cover, but often far harder to distinguish intact native forests from exotic plantations, degraded forest or secondary regrowth," Laurance told mongabay.com, adding that "we need to resolve this, as right now we just don't know what's happening to much of the world's native forests, which are crucial for conserving biodiversity. We might be fooling ourselves into thinking the situation is better than it actually is."
A bleak thought indeed.
CITATION: Jean-Philippe Puyravaud, Priya Davidar, and William Laurance. Cryptic Loss of India's Forests. Science. Vol. 329. July , 2010.
Deadly ‘brown cloud’ over South Asia caused by wood and dung burning
(01/23/2009) Long a subject of debate, the cause of the infamous brown cloud that hovers over the Indian Ocean and South Asia every winter has finally been discovered. Researchers led by Dr Orjan Gustafsson from the University of Stockholm in Sweden announced in Science that 70 percent of the cloud is made up of soot from the burning of biomasses, largely wood and animal dung used for cooking.
Loss of wildlife is threatening biodiverse forests in northeastern India
(09/15/2008) Logging, agricultural expansion, and hunting of large birds and mammals in the tropical forests of northeastern India may be reducing the capacity of the biologically-rich ecosystem to regenerate itself, report researchers writing in the open-access journal Tropical Conservation Science.
Impact of new forest law in India unknown
(12/21/2006) A new law giving land rights to millions of poor Indian forest dwellers is stirring debate in the conservation community according to a report from Reuters.