Site icon Conservation news

Sabah shocked by banteng poaching


A banteng bull and two cows in one of Sabah's protected forests on camera trap. Photo courtesy of Danau Girang Field Centre.

A banteng bull and two cows in one of Sabah’s protected forests on camera trap. Photo courtesy of Danau Girang Field Centre.


Malaysia’s Daily Express recently published graphic photos of poachers in the Malaysian state of Sabah posing proudly with a number of illegally slaughtered large animals, including the incredibly rare and cryptic banteng. Wild, forest cattle, banteng are scattered across parts of Southeast Asia, but Borneo is home to a distinct subspecies: Bos javanicus lowi. According to the Danau Girang Field Centre, only a few hundred survive on the island and, if poaching continues, the subspecies could soon be wiped out altogether.



“It is incredibly saddening to see the carcasses of the animals that we have struggled to research for the past few years, and to continue to witness the ease in which poachers are able to access supposedly protected forests,” said Penny Gardner, who has studied banteng for five years in the state with Cardiff University and Danau Girang Field Centre.



In addition to facing poachers, banteng—like all other rainforest animals in the region—have suffered widespread habitat loss. From 2000 to 2010, Sabah lost more than 15 percent of its forest cover, much of it to oil palm plantations and logging. According to Global Forest Change, Malaysia had the world’s highest deforestation rate—as opposed to total loss—when looking at the period from 2000-2012. During that time, Malaysia lost 14.4 percent of its forest, a rate nearly twice as high as Indonesia.



“Over the past 30-40 years, the banteng has suffered catastrophic events, which have caused their demise and resulted in the local extinction of some herds,” said Penny Gardner, who has studied banteng for five years in the state with Cardiff University and Danau Girang Field Centre. “Their story is similar to many other species in Sabah, such as the Sumatran rhino, orang-utan, sun bear and elephant with the exception of one detail; they are widely unacknowledged.”




A hunter on camera trap in Silabukan Forest Reserve carrying a semi-automatic shotgun. Photo by: Photo courtesy of Danau Girang Field Centre.


Indeed, Benoit Goossens, the Director of Danau Girang Field Centre, said that conservation groups knew of at least three banteng killed by poachers, but they had remained unpunished—and unpublicized—until the recent article in the Daily Express.



“We have been monitoring the banteng population in this area for over four years and they are exceptionally sensitive to human presence and vehicle noise. There is a small breeding population, and the survival of every individual and new calf is crucial,” said Goossens.



In the article highlighting the gruesome poachers’ photos, Forestry Director Sam Mannan said candidly that poaching in Sabah had hit “pandemic proportions.” Part of the problem, he said, was the ease with which poachers have access to forests.



“Sabah is the only State in the country that has lax laws, downright appeasing, on forest reserve entry—consciously laisse faize,”
Mannan told the Daily Express.



He said the poaching wasn’t for subsistence, but largely for trade abroad.



“Until and unless this band of hooligans…are arrested, charged in court, and sentenced severely, the killing field of iconic wildlife…will continue, expand and in the end leave us with a Dead Green Desert–lots of trees but no animals within,” Mannan said.




Poacher captured on camera trap in Sipitang Forest Reserve. Photo by: Photo courtesy of Danau Girang Field Centre.



Last week, conservation groups published a letter accusing authorities of Sabah of not doing nearly enough to combat poaching, including incidents allegedly linked to state security forces.



“We have evidence that the killing is going on and it is time for the public, the government and the NGOs to work together and put a stop to poaching of endangered species in our state,” said Goosens, who asked, “Will we need a banteng’s captive breeding program similar to the Sumatran rhino’s one in Tabin to save the [banteng]?”



Globally, banteng are categorized as Endangered by the IUCN Red List. In addition to Sabah, the wild cattle are found, albeit rarely, in parts of Indonesia, Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand, and Vietnam. The IUCN estimates global population at just 5,000-8,000 animals. Banteng aren’t the only threatened wild, jungle cattle in Asia. The kouprey (Bos sauveli) is even more endangered and may already be extinct. If it is gone, it was likely hunted to extinction.











Related articles


Malaysian authorities failing to take action against poachers

(02/10/2015) Authorities in Sabah are failing to enforce anti-poaching laws, undermining governance and wildlife protection efforts in the Malaysian Borneo state, argues a letter published by several local conservation groups.

Swimming against the stream: a rare crocodile captivates researchers

(02/02/2015) The Sunda gharial looks like ‘just an odd crocodile’ according to Robert Stuebing. He would know. Stuebing and his team have recently published an article in the International Zoo Yearbook outlining habitat information and threats to the Sunda gharial at Lake Mesangat in Indonesian Borneo.

Half of Borneo’s mammals could lose a third of their habitat by 2080

(01/22/2015) Borneo consistently makes the list of the world’s “biodiversity hotspots” – areas full of a wide variety of forms of life found nowhere else, but which are also under threat. To better understand the hazards, a study published today in the journal Current Biology examines the effects of climate change and deforestation in the coming decades on mammals living on the island.

Indonesia’s silent wildlife killer: hunting

(12/26/2014) By and large, Indonesia is a peaceful country. In fact, on the United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime’s list of homicide rates, Indonesia ranks number 10, making Indonesians one of the least murderous people on Earth. A ban on gun ownership probably helps, although obviously there are many other ways to snuff out another person. Maybe Indonesia’s general tendency to avoid conflict helps, too. Whatever the reason why Indonesians are relatively unlikely to kill each other, such favors are not extended to Indonesia’s non-human wildlife. The relative safety of Indonesia’s people does not guarantee similar security for its animals.

Hunting is a greater threat than logging for most wildlife in Borneo

(12/16/2014) Persistence is the key factor in the two most common human stressors on tropical wildlife. In Malaysian Borneo, hunting continually diminishes wildlife populations, whereas the negative impacts from selective logging are more transient, according to a recent study in Conservation Biology.