Global warming may be spurring liana growth, hindering forest carbon storage in Central America
A worrying trend has emerged in tropical forests: lianas, woody long-stemmed vines, are increasingly displacing trees, thereby reducing forests’ overall ability to store carbon.
Researchers from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Stanford University and the University of Pittsburgh, and led by Dr. Stefan A. Schnitzer, studied the impacts of liana-tree competition in central Panamanian treefall gaps. Treefall gaps, known as the “engines of regeneration” in tropical forests, are sites of high growth, carbon accumulation and tree recruitment. However, they are also sites of high liana-tree competition. The researchers studied 17 treefall gaps, regularly cutting all lianas in eight of the gaps while leaving the other nine to grow naturally, thus giving a basis for comparison between the two types of gaps.
Lianas are woody vines, and are found in both temperate and tropical forests. Photo by Schnitzer et al.
Three pieces of bad news
The study, recently published in Ecology, found several detrimental effects of increased liana presence. First, lianas compete with trees for sunlight, soil, water and nutrients, negatively impacting the trees’ reproductive, growth and survival rates. At the end of the study, liana-free treefall gaps were found to have an average tree biomass of nearly three times that of gaps where lianas were allowed to grow naturally.
Second, while lianas do have biomass, their presence in treefall gaps did not make up for the absence of trees. In fact, the lianas in the treefall gaps ultimately displaced 76 percent more tree biomass accumulation compared to the amount that they contributed to woody plant biomass regeneration. This was due to their relatively low wood volume, low wood density, and high rate of mortality and hence, turnover.
“Competition for resources is often considered a zero-sum-game, meaning that, in the terms of carbon, one plant takes the same amount of carbon that its competitor loses,” Schnitzer said. “ Our study showed very clearly that this is not the case.”
Third, because of these two findings, the researchers calculated that in the forest they studied, lianas in treefall gaps displaced 8.9 to 17.8 percent of the forest-level annual biomass accumulation. Considering the enormous role tropical forests play in carbon sequestration, even a small loss in carbon storage capacity translates into a huge amount that stays in the atmosphere. It does not help that the researchers believe their calculated range to be conservative; the actual amount could be much higher.
Lianas can offer benefits to the trees they grow on, such as increased structural stability. However, usually these are outweighed by the drawbacks, and many tree species have evolved mechanisms to fight liana colonization.
And yet, there are many unknowns
Perhaps the most important question, however, remains unclear: why are the lianas slowly conquering the forests? According to Schnitzer, the reasons for the liana increase are still speculative. However, climate change seems to be the most likely culprit, with factors such as more severe seasonal droughts coming into play (lianas seem to prefer the dry and hot conditions found in seasonal forests and treefall gaps compared to ever-wet forests).
Furthermore, while the researchers’ data indicates that the rate of liana growth is still increasing compared to trees, there is not sufficient evidence to see how these rates differ between forests. For instance, liana increases have been documented in Latin American forests and in one North American subtropical forest, but there is not enough information on forests in Africa and Asia.
So what can we do? Should we intervene directly in liana growth? Schnitzer cautions against this, as the long-term effects of liana cutting are still unknown. In addition, removing lianas may reduce the numbers of animal pollinators and seed dispersers, eventually harming tree reproduction.
Rather, he says that we need to fully understand the causes of the increase in liana numbers, what he describes as “a key question that will inform management action.”
- Schnitzer, S. A., van der Heijden, G. M. F., Mascaro, J., & Carson, W. P. (2014). Lianas in Gaps Reduce Carbon Accumulation in a Tropical Forest. Ecology.
(05/16/2014) With the cooperation of hundreds of ranchers and researchers, Azuero Earth Project aims to replant a swath of tropical dry forest, connecting the dry tropical forest on the coast to cloud forest further inland. The trees along the 140-kilometer (80-mile) wildlife corridor will create a continuous habitat for the Critically Endangered Azuero spider monkey (Ateles geoffroyi azuerensis) and improve the soil for people who farm and ranch along the way.
(04/21/2014) Forest disturbance in Malaysia, Bolivia, Panama, and Ecuador surged during the first quarter of 2014, according to NASA data.
(03/19/2014) Mongabay.org, the non-profit arm of environmental science web site Mongabay.com, has selected winners of three environmental reporting prizes under its Special Reporting Initiatives (SRI) program. The three prizes, which were launched in January, explore the impacts of rising human consumption on forest and marine ecosystems. The winners, selected from more than 150 applicants by a panel of issue-area experts, include Robert S. Eshelman, Ruxandra Guidi and Bear Guerra, and Dominic Bracco II and Erik Vance.
(03/19/2014) A new short film, entitled La Trocha, highlights the plight of the Wounaan people in Panama, who are fighting for legal rights to their forests even as loggers and ranchers carve it up. The conflict turned violent in 2012 when local chief, Aquilo Puchicama, was shot dead by loggers.
(01/23/2014) Secondary forests, which are areas that were previously cleared of old-growth cover, now comprise the majority of the forested areas in the United States, Europe, and elsewhere. A heavily debated issue is to what extent secondary forests are able to contribute to the preservation of biodiversity. In an article published in PLOS ONE, a group of researchers from the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute led by Michiel van Breugel evaluated the biodiversity preservation potential of secondary forests.
(01/15/2014) In a study recently published in the online Animal Behavior journal, scientists from the US and the Netherlands have examined the impact of predation patterns on prey’s food foraging habits. The two-year long study on Barro Colorado Island, Panama, focused on the predator-prey relationship between the Central American agouti (Dasyprocta punctata), a common rainforest rodent, and the ocelot (Leopardus pardalis).
(12/26/2013) 2013 was full of major developments in efforts to understand and protect the world’s tropical rainforests. The following is a review of some of the major tropical forest-related news stories for the year. As a review, this post will not cover everything that transpired during 2013 in the world of tropical forests. Please feel free to highlight anything this post missed via the comments section at the bottom. Also please note that this review focuses only on tropical forests.
(12/20/2013) A new study adds further evidence for the ‘sponge effect’ of forests.