Nothing else left to log: are eco-certified timber companies stripping Russia of its last old growth forests?

Shreya Dasgupta, mongabay.com correspondent
August 15, 2014



This article was produced under the Global Forest Reporting Network and can be re-published on your web site or blog or in your magazine, newsletter, or newspaper under these terms.

Russian 'intact forest landscape' loses 100,000 hectares in 12 years due in part to FSC-certified timber companies

Russia’s trees fuel our increasing demand for wood-based products. The country’s vast forests, which cover over 800 million hectares or almost half its land area, are a major source of wood for global timber, paper and pulp industries.

They are also home to some of the world’s most threatened wildlife species such as Siberian tigers and Amur leopards, as well as others like bears and lynx, and act as major carbon sinks.

Among Russia’s forested lands lie intact forest landscapes (or IFLs). These IFLs are large swaths of unbroken, old growth forests that encompass at least 50,000 hectares, harbor high biodiversity, and have remained mostly undisturbed by development. Russia, Canada and Brazil together hold about 65 percent of such IFLs in the world, according to a 2008 study. However, less than 10 percent of the world’s IFLs are currently protected.

A Siberian tiger in the Sikhote-Alin Mountains, Primorye, Russia. Photograph (c) Wildlife Conservation Society Russia Program.
Intact forest landscapes are important for many animals such as this Siberian tiger (Panthera tigris altaica) in the Sikhote-Alin Mountains, Primorye, Russia. Siberian tigers once ranged across huge areas of northern Asia, but today exist only in a small area of intact forest near the Sea of Japan. Photo courtesy of Wildlife Conservation Society Russia Program.

Extensive logging (both legal and illegal), land conversions, road-building, wildfires, and poor forest management practices in Russia have degraded much of its forests. According to recent figures from Global Forest Watch, Russia lost almost 37 million hectares of tree cover from 2001 to 2013.

Russia’s intact forest landscapes, too, are shrinking rapidly due to rampant development.

To address Russia’s deforestation and unsustainable logging of forests, the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) came into Russia in the late 1990s. The FSC is an international non-profit body that certifies “responsible harvesting of forests” by providing a set of “environmentally appropriate, socially beneficial and economically viable” harvesting guidelines to forestry companies. Members of FSC include NGOs (such as WWF and Greenpeace International), research organizations, certification agencies and private logging companies, all of which promote FSC-labeled products to consumers as options that are more sustainable than traditional products.

However, a recent Greenpeace-Russia report casts doubts over FSC-certified green logging in Russia, particularly within intact forest landscapes.

Questioning FSC-certification

“Most of the accessible and valuable forest resources in Russia are more or less gone,” Tatiana Khakimulina, a forest engineer with Greenpeace Russia, told mongabay.com. “The resources that are left remain in the less accessible intact forest landscapes.”

One such IFL, the Dvinsky Forest, lies in the heart of the Arkhangelsk region in northwestern Russia. By analyzing satellite imagery for years 2002 to 2013, Khakimulina’s team found that FSC-certified logging companies were in fact cutting through high conservation value forests like Dvinsky unsustainably, instead of upholding FSC’s principles that aim to maintain their integrity.


Satellite image of Northern Dvina-Pinega (Dvinsky IFL) showing the different forest cover types. Courtesy of Greenpeace Russia. Click to enlarge.


An overview of former or current FSC-certified companies operating in Dvinsky forest. Map by Greenpeace Russia. Click to enlarge.

Recent figures from Global Forest Watch show that the Dvinsky forest lost almost 100,000 hectares of tree cover between 2002 and 2013.

“The forest logging companies see these IFLs as the main source of wood for them. And they actually base their wood supply on these IFLs.” Khakimulina said. “This is where there is a contradiction between FSC standards, and what is actually happening on ground.”

According to the report, local environmental NGOs had initially welcomed FSC certification of the Dvinsky IFL hoping that it would help protect it. However, after 14 years of FSC presence in the region, “large areas of forest within the IFL have already been destroyed,” the report states.

The report’s findings show that logging by the five companies under consideration was much higher than sustainable limits during the study period. In addition, the companies also appeared to have cut through forests that lie inside the borders of proposed protected areas in the region.

Moreover, outside the proposed protected areas, the five logging companies failed to comply with FSC’s standards on numerous accounts. In fact, the team states that the annual harvesting amount and rates have far exceeded values that which can be permanently sustained in the region. These practices are irreversibly destroying the forests.

Greenpeace’s contention, thus, is that instead of trying to eliminate destructive forest practices, FSC in Russia is actually “endorsing them.”


Dvinsky has lost nearly 100,000 hectares of forest in just over a decade. Map courtesy of Global Forest Watch. Click to enlarge.


Time-lapse of tree cover loss in the Dvinsky IFL between 2002-2013. Courtesy of Global Forest Watch. Click to enlarge.

What FSC stakeholders say

The Forest Stewardship Council, however, disagrees with the report's stance.

In response to the Greenpeace report, FSC has stated on its website that “the Dvinsky Forest region is an example for effective stakeholder engagement processes that has resulted in strong and lasting solutions for threatened forest species and ecosystems.”

The FSC response added that the FSC-certification bodies have effective control measures in place that ensure strong disciplinary action against companies that fail to comply with FSC standards.

“Three of the five forest management certificates referred to in the Greenpeace article were suspended between December 2013 and February 2014 because they did not comply with FSC requirements; a fourth one had already expired earlier and was not renewed,” the FSC response stated. “It is fair to say that without FSC certification or under less rigorous certification schemes these forests might have been logged already.”

Vladislav Kheynonen, a certification manager with NEPCon Russia, an FSC-accredited certification and auditing body that suspended two of the logging companies in the region, pointed out some potential limitations of the report.

“The report does not distinguish between logging that took place during the period of certification, and logging that took place prior to, or after, the companies were certified….,” he said. “The case study of the Dvinskiy forest is also a good example of how certification practices have changed over time. Some practices that were deemed appropriate in 2002 under the FSC rules are impossible today. Unfortunately, the report does not focus on this key point.”


Logging road like these inside Dvinsky Forest lead to fragmentation and degradation of IFLs. Photo courtesy of Greenpeace.

According to Kheynonen, FSC has great potential in Russia. “Today FSC is the most advanced and influential forest certification system in the world,” he said. “This is because it develops high-quality standards in close collaboration with environmental, social and economic stakeholders.”

However, he added that the current Russian national FSC Forest Management Standard is too bureaucratic and unclear, especially when it comes to its environmental indicators.

“Work is on-going to revise the Russian national FSC standard. So hopefully this will improve,” he said.

Andrey Shegolev, head of the Arkhangelsk branch of WWF Russia, told mongabay.com that WWF Russia generally shares the FSC’s position stated in their response to the Greenpeace report. However, he agreed that the FSC system has its share of problems.

One main problem, according to Shegolev, is the way in which the maximum allowed annual harvesting volumes are calculated. In addition, until recently there was no alternate way of calculating the allowable harvest limits that the FSC could use, he added.

Alexey Yaroshenko, Forest Department head of Greenpeace Russia, agreed that the annual allowable cut is usually several times higher than what is sustainable.

“For example, the annual allowable cut for the entire Arkhangelsk region is more than 25 million cubic meters per year. This is what is allowed to be lopped for the whole region,” Yaroshenko said. “But the actual sustainable volume is significantly less than 10 million cubic meters per year.”

While alternative sustainable calculations are now available with FSC, Yaroshenko thinks it will be a while before any of these are implemented. “We do not believe that these will turn into a practical decision without [a] strong external push in the coming years,” he said.


Road adjacent to large clearcut inside Dvinsky Forest. Photo courtesy of Greenpeace.

The way forward

Greenpeace Russia has developed a list of recommendations that it hopes will make FSC presence in Russia more credible and effective. According to one recommendation, FSC must certify logging operations in high conservation value forests or IFLs only after a protected area network is established within them. In addition, FSC must gradually stop certifying companies within intact forest landscapes.

“We understand that it is not possible to do this immediately, but we estimate that this can be done in the next five years” Yaroshenko said. “For example, all existing certificates will expire after five years. So if FSC now stops giving out certificates for new development inside the IFLs, this will eventually lead to a no-FSC policy, and thus no development in IFLs.”

Another recommendation is that the FSC services should take into consideration not only the total forest volume in their calculation of annually permissible harvests, but forest conservation, protected areas and ecosystem services as well.

Kheynonen added that the FSC standards are only as good as their implementation.

“Strict observance of the rules is key to the success of FSC,” he said. “And protection of intact forest landscapes requires close attention from the landowner, the State. Assigning formal protection status to these areas would thus be the most important action that can be taken.”


A temporary railway constructed for the transportation of cut logs. Photo courtesy of Greenpeace.


Intact forest abuts a cleared strip in the Arkhangelsk region. Photo courtesy of Greenpeace.









blog comments powered by Disqus



The Global Forest Reporting Network is a joint effort between Mongabay.org and World Resources Institute (WRI) that sources data-driven, forest-focused stories from an international network of journalists.

REPUBLISH THIS ARTICLE

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

We strongly encourage anyone to republish this article online and in print, as long as you follow some simple guidelines:

  • You have to credit the author and Mongabay.org as listed in the original piece, ideally in the byline, with a link back to the specific article URL [in this case: http://news.mongabay.com/2014/0815-gfrn-dasgupta-russia-greenpeace-fsc.html] on Mongabay's website.
  • This article is published under the Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0) Creative Commons license. That means you cannot edit or change the material, except to reflect relative changes in time, location and basic editorial style (For example, "yesterday" can be changed to "last week," and "London, UK." to "London" or "here", and "organization" to "organisation"). To request material edits contact us.
  • You can print the first few sentences of the article and then say: “Read the full article on Mongabay.com” with a link back to the article page on our site.
  • If you are republishing online, you must link to us, include the original links embedded in the story, and embed our view counter in your republished version. See below for embed instructions.
  • It is okay to put our articles on pages with ads, but you cannot sell our material separately.
  • Pay attention to photo permissions. If a photo in the original piece is credited as belonging to either Mongabay or the author of the piece you are republishing, you have permission to use the photo as is, unchanged, with the same caption/credit as used in the original piece. If an image is copyright of another photographer or illustrator and you would like to reproduce it, contact us. Some sources don't allow their images to be republished without permission.

Read more about our Republishing Guidelines.

Instructions for embedding the required view counter.

The view counter consists of a one pixel image, which is activated by using the following code in your page where the article runs:
    <img src="http://www.google-analytics.com/collect?v=1&tid=UA-12973256-1&cid=grn&t=event&ea=open&cs=news&cm=gfrn&cn=/2014/0815-gfrn-dasgupta-russia-greenpeace-fsc.html">
The pixel, which is hosted by Google, will not meaningfully affect your page load.

×




Related articles



No restrictions: Japan's demand for illegal wood driving rampant deforestation in Siberia

(07/03/2014) Illegal logging is taking a huge toll on forests around the world. In response, many countries have banned the import of timber whose legal harvest cannot be verified. However, Japan has made no strides to reduce its import of illegal timber. Instead, it is knowingly importing mass quantities of wood sourced from vulnerable forests in Siberia, according to a recent report.


Chinese fishermen get the ultimate phone video: a swimming tiger

(06/19/2014) Two Chinese fishermen got the catch of their lives...on mobile phone this week. While fishing in the Ussuri River, which acts as a border between Russia and China, the fishermen were approached by a swimming Siberian tiger. These tigers, also known as Amur tigers, are down to around 350-500 animals.


Ignoring boreal forests could speed up global warming

(06/04/2014) Greenhouse gas emissions from human activity have caused global air and sea surface temperatures to rise approximately 0.8 Celsius (1.4 degrees Fahrenheit) since the beginning of the 20th century, contributing to a plethora of problems worldwide from rising sea levels to desertification. A new study finds that global temperatures may start to increase even faster if more is not done to protect Earth’s boreal forests.


31 activists arrested attempting to stop Arctic oil from docking in Europe

(05/01/2014) Dutch police arrested 31 Greenpeace activists today, who were attempting to block the Russian oil tanker, Mikhail Ulyanov, from delivering the first shipment of offshore Arctic oil to the European market.


3M linked to deforestation in Brazil, Canada, Europe, and U.S., says NGO

(04/29/2014) A new report from activist group, ForestEthics, alleges that U.S. company, 3M, supplies many of its products from endangered forests around the world. The NGO links 3M's masking tape and sandpaper to caribou habitat in the boreal forests of Canada, Scotch-Brite sponges to a controversial paper mill in Brazil, and those ubiquitous Post-it Notes to allegedly poor logging practices in the U.S.


The remarkable story of how a bat scientist took on Russia's most powerful...and won

(04/28/2014) In a country increasingly known for its authoritarian-style crackdown on activists and dissidents, a bat scientist has won a number of impressive victories to protect the dwindling forests of the Western Caucasus. For his efforts, Gazaryan was awarded today with the Goldman Environmental Prize, often called the Nobel Prize for the environment, along with five other winners around the world.


Europe votes for an Arctic Sanctuary

(03/13/2014) Yesterday, the European Parliament passed a resolution supporting the creation of an Arctic Sanctuary covering the vast high Arctic around the North Pole, giving official status to an idea that has been pushed by activists for years. Still, the sanctuary has a long road to go before becoming a reality: as Arctic sea ice rapidly declines due to climate change, there has been rising interest from governments and industries to exploit the once inaccessible wilderness for fish and fossil fuels.


World first: Russia begins pumping oil from Arctic seabed

(12/23/2013) Oil has begun to be pumped from the Arctic seabed, according to Russian oil giant, Gazprom. The company announced on Friday that it has begun exploiting oil reserves at the offshore field of Prirazlomnoye. The project, which is several years behind schedule, is hugely controversial and made international headlines in September after Russian military arrested 28 Greenpeace activists protesting the operation along with a British journalist and Russian videographer.


World suffers warmest November on record

(12/18/2013) Last month was the warmest November on record, according to new analysis from the NOAA. Temperatures were 0.78 degrees Celsius (1.40 degrees Fahrenheit) above the average November in the 20th Century. Global temperatures are on the rise due to climate change caused primarily by burning fossil fuels, but also by deforestation and land-use change.


Top 10 Environmental Stories of 2013

(12/10/2013) 1. Carbon concentrations hit 400ppm while the IPCC sets global carbon budget: For the first time since our appearance on Earth, carbon concentrations in the atmosphere hit 400 parts per million. The last time concentrations were this high for a sustained period was 4-5 million years ago when temperatures were 10 degrees Celsius higher. Meanwhile, in the slow-moving effort to curb carbon emissions, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) crafted a global carbon budget showing that most of the world's fossil fuel reserves must be left untouched if we are to avoid catastrophic climate change.




CITATION:
Shreya Dasgupta, mongabay.com correspondent (August 15, 2014).

Nothing else left to log: are eco-certified timber companies stripping Russia of its last old growth forests? .

http://news.mongabay.com/2014/0815-gfrn-dasgupta-russia-greenpeace-fsc.html