Court partially stops Japan's 'scientific' whaling, but Pacific harvests to continue

Morgan Erickson-Davis
April 01, 2014



Japan has harvested thousands of whales in North Pacific and Antarctic waters since the implementation of a global ban on whaling, eliciting harsh criticism from the international community. Now, in a landmark decision, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) has ruled that Japan must cease its whaling activities in the Antarctic.

The advent of factory ships, exploding harpoons and other technologies allowed commercial whaling industries to harvest huge numbers of whales in the 19th and 20th centuries. By the 1930s, total global kills amounted to more than 50,000 animals annually, far exceeding sustainable limits. Among the most impacted species were blue whales, right whales and gray whales, which were reduced by upwards of 95 percent.

To curtail population losses and reduce the risk of extinctions, the International Whaling Commission (IWC) implemented a global ban on commercial whaling in 1986. However, a handful of countries objected to the ban and allowed their large-scale whaling practices to persist. Among them, Japan continued whaling for purported research purposes, reporting annual catches of 600-1300 animals for both its North Pacific and Antarctic fleets.

A minke whale and her one-year-old calf are dragged aboard the Nisshin Maru, a Japanese whaling vessel (2008). Photo courtesy of the Australian Customs and Border Protection Service.
A minke whale and her one-year-old calf are dragged aboard the Nisshin Maru, a Japanese whaling vessel (2008). Photo courtesy of the Australian Customs and Border Protection Service.

The scientific validity of Japan’s whaling has been questioned by environmental organizations and other nations. In 2010, Australia brought a case against Japan via the ICJ, arguing it disguised its commercial whaling activities as research so that it could take advantage of a loophole in the 1986 moratorium. In its ruling, the ICJ stated that although Japan had caught approximately 3,600 minke whales since 2005, scientific output was scarce. The meat from harvested whales is widely available at public markets.

“This is a historic decision which lays to rest, once and for all, the grim travesty of Japan’s so-called ‘scientific’ whaling and exposes it to the world as the blatant falsehood it clearly is,” said Clare Perry, of the Environmental Investigation Agency. “For a long time it has been evident that ‘science’ has been abused at a breath-taking scale to justify Japan’s continued commercial hunting of protected whales and despite a heavily subsidized and ever-dwindling market for whale meat in Japan.”

The ruling takes effect immediately, with Japan ordered by the ICJ not to issue future permits. However, it remains possible for Japan to revamp its whaling program by reducing quotas that, until now, have been largely self-imposed. If that is the case, the IWC may allow Japan to continue Antarctic whaling.

“The ruling is final; there is no appeal. It is up to Japan to comply and they have said they will,” Perry told mongabay.com. “However, there is nothing to stop them devising a new ‘scientific’ whaling program which seeks to address some of the concerns raised in the ICJ case. This is clearly a possibility, but on the other hand one of the greatest concerns was the scale of the hunt and the fact that the research could be carried out using non-lethal methods, so it’s hard to imagine how Japan could address those concerns to anyone’s satisfaction – almost by definition they would have to take fewer whales.”

The ICJ ruling concerns only the Antarctic program, leaving Japan free to continue whaling in the North Pacific, where whale populations are even smaller and more vulnerable to human pressures. A 2007 census estimated only 7,700 sei whales exist in the North Pacific.

“What we would like to see as a next step would be countries in the northern hemisphere follow up with a case against Japan’s North Pacific hunt,” Perry said. “This takes hundreds of whales – minke, sei, sperm and Bryde’s whales – and all the same issues apply to this fake science program that applied to Japan’s Antarctic whaling.”

Japan harvest rates 1985-2010, compiled using IWC data and released to the public domain.
Japan harvest rates 1985-2010, compiled using IWC data and released to the public domain.















Related articles

Scientists spy on whales from space

(03/11/2014) Although whales are the biggest animals on the planet, scientists have found in difficult to count them. But a new study in PLOS ONE may change this: researchers tested the idea of counting whales using high resolution satellite imagery. Employing a single image from the WorldView2 satellite, scientists went about counting a pod of southern right whales in the Golfo Nuevo off the coast of Argentina.


Scientists discover new whale species

(02/14/2014) Beaked whales are incredibly elusive and rare, little-known to scientists and the public alike—although some species are three times the size of an elephant. Extreme divers, beaked whales have been recorded plunging as deep as 1,800 meters (5,900 feet) for over an hour. Few of the over 20 species are well-known by researchers, but now scientists have discovered a new beaked whale to add to the already large, and cryptic, group: the pointed beaked whale (Mesoplodon hotaula).


Incredible encounter: whales devour European eels in the darkness of the ocean depths

(02/11/2014) The Critically Endangered European eel makes one of the most astounding migrations in the wild kingdom. After spending most of its life in Europe's freshwater rivers, the eel embarks on an undersea odyssey, traveling 6,000 kilometers (3,720 miles) to the Sargasso Sea where it will spawn and die. The long-journeying eels larva than make their way back to Europe over nearly a year. Yet by tracking adult European eels (Anguilla anguilla) with electronic data loggers, scientists have discovered that some eels never make it to their spawning ground, but instead are swallowed-up in the depths by leviathans.


Photos: Japanese fishermen slaughter 41 dolphins, capture 52 in 'The Cove'

(01/21/2014) The annual dolphin hunt in Taiji, Japan ended on Monday with dozens being slaughtered for meat and captured for sale to amusement parks, reports Sea Shepherd, an ocean activist group that campaigns against the practice and just released photos documenting the weekend's harvest.


Japanese whale hunt stopped, for now

(01/06/2014) Anti-whaling group Sea Shepherd said its fleet of ships has successfully disrupted the annual Japanese whale hunt in the waters off Antarctica.


Activists urge Southwest to drop SeaWorld over whale concerns

(01/06/2014) More than 27,000 people have signed a petition calling on Southwest Airlines Co. (LUV) to drop its partnership with SeaWorld Entertainment, Inc. (NYSE:SEAS), over the theme park's treatment of its marine mammals, reports Change.org, the site that is hosting the petition.




CITATION:
Morgan Erickson-Davis (April 01, 2014).

Court partially stops Japan's 'scientific' whaling, but Pacific harvests to continue.

http://news.mongabay.com/2014/0401-morgan-japan-whaling-icj.html