Indonesia should convert logging concessions to protected areas to stop deforestation for plantations, argues studyRhett A. Butler, mongabay.com
September 05, 2013
Deforestation for an oil palm plantation in Central Kalimantan in 2013. Photo by Rhett A. Butler..
The study, which involved an international team of researchers led by David Gaveau of the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), analyzed forest loss in areas zoned for different uses in Indonesian Borneo. It found that deforestation rates in timber concessions and protected areas were "not significantly different" provided logging concessions were not reclassified as industrial plantation concessions. The results suggest that designating existing logging concessions as permanent forest estates to prevent their conversion to oil palm plantations could generate substantial conservation benefits in Indonesia, according to the authors.
"Our study indicates the desirability of the Government of Indonesia designating its natural forest timber concessions as protected areas under the IUCN Protected Area Category VI, because they perform as effectively as protected areas in maintaining forest cover and should be protected from reclassification," the researchers write.
"Adding Kalimantan’s natural forest timber concessions to the protected area network would increase the permanently protected forest in Kalimantan by 248,305 square kilometers."
That would effectively put two-thirds of Kalimantan's remaining forest cover under some form of protection. Meanwhile those logging concessions would still generate revenue for local communities, companies, and the state, offering a strong financial incentive for maintaining them, according to the paper. That incentive is currently missing in many Indonesian protected areas, which suffer from high rates of encroachment, illegal logging, fire, and deforestation due to inadequate levels of funding.
Although they note the shortcomings of underfunded parks, the researchers do not call for converting protected areas to logging concessions. Instead they view existing logging concessions as a potentially inexpensive opportunity for augmenting conservation areas. Indeed, while selectively logged forests have lower levels of biodiversity and are more susceptible to drought and fire than old-growth forests, they have far higher conservation value and store vastly more carbon than oil palm plantations, which other biologists have likened to biological deserts.
"Logged forests can still be extremely valuable habitats for orangutans and other species," write the authors, who include three prominent orangutan conservationists. "The creation of the 5,686 sq km Sebangau National Park in 2004, an area logged throughout the 1990s, but containing the largest contiguous orangutan population on Borneo, indicates that Government of Indonesia is beginning to recognize the value of logged forests for biodiversity conservation."
Map showing the change of land use status of area allocated for natural timber harvesting and protected areas during 2000–2010 in Kalimantan. Area allocated for natural timber harvesting in 2000 and 2010 (light green); Protected area in 2000 and 2010 (dark green); Area allocated for natural timber harvesting in 2000 reclassified to industrial plantation concessions in 2010 (red); Area allocated for natural timber harvesting in 2000 reclassified to protected area in 2010 (orange); Protected area in 2000 reclassified to industrial plantation concessions in 2010 (yellow). Image and caption courtesy of the authors.
Indonesia currently has a moratorium on granting new logging permits in old-growth forests. That moratorium was a product of Norway's billion dollar grant to reduce deforestation in the country.
Indonesia has one of the highest deforestation rates in the world. Between 2009 and 2011 it lost an average of 620,000 hectares of forest per year, or more than a third higher what the Brazilian Amazon lost last year.
CITATION: Gaveau DLA, Kshatriya M, Sheil D, Sloan S, Molidena E, et al. (2013) Reconciling Forest Conservation and Logging in Indonesian Borneo. PLoS ONE 8(8):e69887. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0069887
|AUTHOR: Rhett Butler founded Mongabay in 1999. He currently serves as president, head writer, and chief editor.|
Experts: sustainable logging in rainforests impossible
(07/19/2012) Industrial logging in primary tropical forests that is both sustainable and profitable is impossible, argues a new study in Bioscience, which finds that the ecology of tropical hardwoods makes logging with truly sustainable practices not only impractical, but completely unprofitable. Given this, the researchers recommend industrial logging subsidies be dropped from the UN's Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD+) program. The study, which adds to the growing debate about the role of logging in tropical forests, counters recent research making the case that well-managed logging in old-growth rainforests could provide a "middle way" between conservation and outright conversion of forests to monocultures or pasture.
Industrial logging leaves a poor legacy in Borneo's rainforests
(07/17/2012) For most people "Borneo" conjures up an image of a wild and distant land of rainforests, exotic beasts, and nomadic tribes. But that place increasingly exists only in one's imagination, for the forests of world's third largest island have been rapidly and relentlessly logged, burned, and bulldozed in recent decades, leaving only a sliver of its once magnificent forests intact. Flying over Sabah, a Malaysian state that covers about 10 percent of Borneo, the damage is clear. Oil palm plantations have metastasized across the landscape. Where forest remains, it is usually degraded. Rivers flow brown with mud.
Conservation areas failing to protect forests better than logging concessions in Sumatra
(06/28/2012) Areas zoned for conservation suffered deforestation rates similar to logging concessions in Sumatra between 1990 and 2000, but maintained forest cover more effectively than lands allocated for agricultural conversion, reports a study published in Conservation Letters.
Logged rainforests are a cheap conservation option
(09/14/2011) With old-growth forests fast diminishing and land prices surging across Southeast Asia due to rising returns from timber and agricultural commodities, opportunities to save some of the region's rarest species seem to be dwindling. But a new paper, published in the journal Conservation Letters, highlights an often overlooked opportunity for conservation: selectively logged forests.