About  |   Contact  |  Mongabay on Facebook  |  Mongabay on Twitter  |  Subscribe
Rainforests | Tropical fish | Environmental news | Blog | For kids | Madagascar | Photos | Non-English languages | Tropical Conservation Science | Jobs
SHARE:




New plan would pay tropical countries for protecting terrestrial carbon, regardless of where it is stored
mongabay.com
July 24, 2008 [Corrected Aug 5, 2008]




Deforestation and forest degradation account for around a fifth of global carbon emissions from human activities, but new policy measures are focusing reducing such emissions as a cost-effective way to fight global warming. While the concept — known as REDD for "Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation" — has found wide support from politicians, scientists, and environmentalists, there are lingering concerns over how to compensate countries that have extensive forest cover and low rates of annual forest loss, since payments are based on historical deforestation rates. A new proposal seeks to get around this issue by factoring in all the terrestrial carbon in a tropical landscape — regardless of where it is stored — and packaging it as a tradable commodity.

The concept is presented in a paper by the Terrestrial Carbon Group, a group of scientists, economists and public policy experts. The paper, "How to Include Terrestrial Carbon in Developing Nations in the Overall Climate Change Solution" (PDF), lays out a series of "guiding principles" for action to address emissions from terrestrial carbon sources.



"The Terrestrial Carbon Group's paper recognizes that over the coming decades, vegetated land in developing nations will be increasingly threatened with conversion to agricultural and plantation use, and to human settlements and infrastructure. This will cause greenhouse gas emissions, underscoring the ongoing importance of terrestrial carbon in the climate change solution," said Terrestrial Carbon Group in a statement.

"Both market and non-market approaches to terrestrial carbon and climate change are necessary. Within that context, the Terrestrial Carbon Group proposes a market-based system that includes all the components that would need to be agreed at an international level (whether bilateral, multilateral or global)."

"Nations would determine national and sub-national implementation systems targeted to their specific circumstances. The proposed system is as simple as possible and has two purposes: (i) to allow the international trading (whether bilateral, multilateral, or global) of carbon credits based on the maintenance and creation of terrestrial carbon, and (ii) to guarantee that action under the system contributes to long-term climate change mitigation."

The group says its plan "encourages broad participation because it provides incentives to developing nations regardless of their historic rates of deforestation and terrestrial carbon emissions."

In other words countries that would potentially lose out from the currently-proposed REDD mechanism — nations like Guyana, Suriname, and DR Congo — could cash in on their forest stewardship, earning funds to continue conservation efforts and improving the quality of life of people living in and around forests.

"Our proposed system does not restrict economic use of land, but instead opens up one new economic development option — generating and selling terrestrial carbon credits. This puts a new economic value on terrestrial carbon, including trees, soil and peat," said Terrestrial Carbon Group member, Dr Chatib Basri of the Institute for Economic and Social Research at the University of Indonesia.

How it would work

Ralph Ashton, who leads the Terrestrial Carbon Group, told mongabay.com that the proposal "first categorizes all terrestrial carbon into protected and tradable, and then pays to keep the tradable terrestrial carbon. The protected terrestrial carbon must be retained for the nation (or sub-national entities) to remain eligible for payments.

"It is therefore not a carbon stock approach that rewards the maintenance of all forest carbon, but an avoided emissions approach using terrestrial carbon stocks and a protected / tradable categorization to set the baseline," he continued. "The level of threat determines whether particular terrestrial carbon is tradable or protected."

The group says that the proposed system also overcomes some of the other criticisms of forest carbon trading initiatives, including "permanence" (whether a county can ensure that forest carbon savings are permanent); "leakage" (what happens when carbon conservation in one area drives deforestation in another?); baseline data establishment (how does one measure historic deforestation to establish a baseline for calculating reduction?); and "additionality" (how is it determined that the carbon offset adds to the decrease of carbon dioxide content in the atmosphere?). The system would limit number of credits that can be sold each year, buoying market prices, while it would require countries to maintain protected areas.

"The good news is that, while some uncertainty remains, we know how to use forests and land management as part of the climate change solution. The science, the economics, and the drivers of land-use decisions are all well enough understood. And the institutional arrangements are possible," said Terrestrial Carbon Group member, Dr Thomas Lovejoy of the Heinz Center.

"Climate change is not just an environmental issue; it has impacts on all facets of life in developed and developing nations alike. Avoiding dangerous climate change is an essential task for the whole world. It is a difficult task, and we must therefore use all available means," added Terrestrial Carbon Group member, Professor Hadi Soesastro of CSIS in Indonesia.

"Terrestrial carbon is a critical untapped element that could provide up to 25% of the climate change solution," added Ashton.

  • The Terrestrial Carbon Group
  • TCG's Blueprint




    Related articles

    Low deforestation countries to see least benefit from carbon trading August 13, 2007
    Countries that have done the best job protecting their tropical forests stand to gain the least from proposed incentives to combat global warming through carbon offsets, warns a new study published in Tuesday in the journal Public Library of Science Biology (PLoS). The authors say that "high forest cover with low rates of deforestation" (HFLD) nations "could become the most vulnerable targets for deforestation if the Kyoto Protocol and upcoming negotiations on carbon trading fail to include intact standing forest."

    Guyana's forests offered as massive carbon offset November 26, 2007
    Guyana has offered up the entirety of its remaining forest cover as a giant carbon offset, reports The Independent. Guyana's President, Bharrat Jagdeo, has offered to place the country's extensive rainforests under the control of an international body in exchange for "development aid" and "technical assistance needed to make the change to a green economy."

    Carbon market could fund rainforest conservation, fight climate change May 19, 2008
    A mechanism to fund forest conservation through the carbon market could significantly reduce greenhouse emissions, help preserve biodiversity, and improve rural livelihoods, says a policy expert with the Woods Hole Research Center (WHRC) in Massachusetts. In an interview with mongabay.com, WHRC Policy Advisor and Research Associate Tracy Johns says that Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation (REDD), a proposed policy mechanism for combating climate change by safeguarding forests and the carbon they store, offers great potential for protecting tropical rainforests.

    REDD will fail if needs of forest communities aren't addressed December 7, 2007
    Initiatives to reduce emissions by reducing tropical deforestation (REDD) will fail unless policymakers adequately address the underlying drivers of forest degradation and destruction, argues a new report published by the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR).

    More avoided deforestation news









    CITATION:
    mongabay.com (July 24, 2008). New plan would pay tropical countries for saving forests, regardless of level of threat. http://news.mongabay.com/2008/0724-forest_carbon.html


    Tags:
    redd avoided deforestation carbon finance carbon conservation carbon offsets carbon sequestration carbon credits carbon trading rainforests deforestation carbon dioxide happy-upbeat environmental forests carbon emissions asia global warminig mitigation africa conservation environment saving the rainforest green

    print


    News index | RSS | News Feed | Twitter | Home


    Advertisements:


    Organic Apparel from Patagonia | Insect-repelling clothing




    Mongabay Store
    Wildlife of Madagascar T-shirt
    Wildlife of Madagascar T-shirt
    Bold and Dangerous - Pygmy tyrant t-shirts
    Bold and Dangerous - Pygmy tyrant
    Love me before I'm gone - Gladiator frog t-shirts
    Love me before I'm gone - Gladiator frog
    Licking this frog may make you crazy t-shirts
    Licking this frog may make you crazy





  • WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
    Email:





    SUPPORT
    Mongabay.com seeks to raise interest in and appreciation of wild lands and wildlife, while examining the impact of emerging trends in climate, technology, economics, and finance on conservation and development (more)

    Help support mongabay.com when you buy from Amazon.com



    POPULAR PAGES
    Rainforests
    Rain forests
    Amazon deforestation
    Deforestation
    Deforestation stats
    Why rainforests matter
    Saving rainforests
    Deforestation stats
    Rainforest canopy

    News
    Most popular articles
    Worth saving?
    Forest conservation
    Earth Day
    Poverty alleviation
    Cell phones in Africa
    Seniors helping Africa
    Saving orangutans in Borneo
    Palm oil
    Amazon palm oil
    Future of the Amazon
    Cane toads
    Dubai environment
    Investing to save rainforests
    Visiting the rainforest
    Biomimicry
    Defaunation
    Blue lizard
    Amazon fires
    Extinction debate
    Extinction crisis
    Blackwashing
    Industrial deforestation
    Save the Amazon
    Rainforests & REDD
    Brazil's Amazon plan
    Malaysian palm oil
    Avatar story
    New Guinea
    Sulawesi
    Amazon ranching
    Madagascar
    Borneo

    News topics
    Amazon
    Biofuels
    Brazil
    Carbon Finance
    Conservation
    Climate Change
    Deforestation
    Energy
    Happy-upbeat
    Indonesia
    Interviews
    Oceans
    Palm oil
    Rainforests
    REDD
    Solutions
    Wildlife
    MORE TOPICS



    Non-English Sites
    Chinese
    French
    German
    Greek
    Indonesian
    Italian
    Portuguese
    Spanish
    Other languages

    Nature Blog Network









    Photos
    Alaska photos
    Alaska

    Argentina photos
    Argentina

    Australia photos
    Australia

    Belize photos
    Belize

    Brazil photos
    Brazil

    Cambodia photos
    Cambodia

    China photos
    China

    Colombia photos
    Colombia

    Costa Rica photos
    Costa Rica

    Deforestation photos
    Deforestation

    Frog photos
    Frog

    Gabon photos
    Gabon

    Grand Canyon photos
    Grand Canyon

    Honduras photos
    Honduras

    India photos
    India

    Indonesia photos
    Indonesia

    Kenya photos
    Kenya

    Laos photos
    Laos

    Lemur photos
    Lemur

    Madagascar photos
    Madagascar

    Malaysia photos
    Malaysia

    Monkey photos
    Monkey

    New Zealand photos
    New Zealand

    Panama photos
    Panama

    Peru photos
    Peru

    Peru photos
    Rainforest


    Sunset

    Suriname photos
    Suriname

    Tanzania photos
    Tanzania

    Thailand photos
    Thailand

    Uganda photos
    Uganda

    United States photos
    United States

    Venezuela photos
    Venezuela



    HIGH RESOLUTION PHOTOS / PRINTS


    CALENDARS
  • Mount Kenya
  • East Africa Safari Wildlife
  • Kenya's Turkana People
  • Peru
  • African Wildlife
  • Alaska
  • China
  • Madagascar Chameleons


    CANVAS BAGS

  • Hallucinogenic frog bag
  • Madagascar wildlife bag








  • Copyright mongabay 2010

    Carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions generated from mongabay.com operations (server, data transfer, travel) are mitigated through an association with Anthrotect,
    an organization working with Afro-indigenous and Embera communities to protect forests in Colombia's Darien region.
    Anthrotect is protecting the habitat of mongabay's mascot: the scale-crested pygmy tyrant.